When dealing with Remakes of classic movies, directors can either capture all of the key elements and strong points of a film or completely miss necessary facets of the movie. When Tim Burton remade the classic movie Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory (1971) in 2005-it came nowhere near the excellence in comparison with the Original. Charlie and the Chocolate Factory (2005) and Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory (1971) have similarities involving the plot, in the sense that both movies seemed to tell the same story.But the two movies also have some major differences that make and break the film; the plot, theme and acting were those key differences. Charlie and the Chocolate Factory (2005) had a confusing chain of events, a strange message, and an even stranger Willy Wonka portrayed by Johnny Depp. While Willy Wonka and the Chocolate factory (1971) is by far more of a quality movie with an easy to read message, interesting line of events and Gene wilder brilliantly played the role of Willy Wonka.
It’s a movie that takes its viewer to a magical chocolate factory and teaches the importance of family and honesty. The plot of the two movies was relatively similar with generally the same idea. Although the two plots were fairly similar, the story was portrayed much nicer in the original. In the movies Charlie was one of five lucky children to win a tour into Wonka’s Chocolate Factory. Each of the children found a golden ticket inside a Wonka candy bar.
The tour was special because Wonka was such a recluse, and nobody had seen him or the inside of his factory for decades.Each of the five children was told that one child would win a special prize presented by Wonka at the end of the tour. The theme of the 2005 version is one of importance of family.
In the Remake Charlie chooses his family over the chocolate factory when given the choice from Willy Wonka. He would rather have his poor family than no family at all and an entire chocolate factory. Also he won the chocolate factory because he simply obeyed all of Mr. Wonka’s rules.The main idea of the remake is to convey good behavior versus bad but has a lot of strange humor, such as eerie childhood flashbacks, which kills the mysteriousness and intrigue surrounding the character of Willy Wonka. This entails confusion of some sort and conflicts the main idea of making good choices. Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory (1971) has a straightforward theme.
The theme or idea of the movie was the importance of telling the truth. When Charlie gave Mr. Wonka his Gobstopper back, he was simply forgiven for drinking theFizzing Lifting Drink and given the entire factory. In the original the main idea and theme was presented through consequence and action, by doing this it made the film easier to understand, more interesting, and fluent.
Acting was a huge point of comparison in these two films. In the remake Johnny Depp plays Willy Wonka. Depp portrays Wonka as a somewhat lost and uncanny adult with a child like mind. He is timid and acts almost like a kid. His performance in this movie was beyond abnormal. In the original Gene Wilder portrayed Willy Wonka as a magical and mysterious man.
Gene Wilder blew away Johnny Depps performance by truly fitting the characters description, Intriguing, somewhat creepy and yet sweet all at the same time. Gene Wilder made the movie more interesting and was a great character. While Depp made the film creepier and off kilter, Wilder made the film magical yet creepily enchanting. When Johnny Depp was first introduced as Willy Wonka he was brought in by surprise almost. When the puppets were performing he watched behind the crowd and surprised them by clapping at the end of the performance.This introduction to him was rather shy and weird which didn’t set a good tone for the rest of the performance of him as an actor. While Gene Wilder had a grand entrance where he began limping then went into a forward roll, welcoming his guests to the chocolate factory.
This was a more warm and welcome introduction to his character that made his performance more interesting and almost dynamic. Gene Wilder really rode the line between charming and downright scary. Depps acting completely lacked the weird charm of the original, replacing it with flashy but completely lifeless stuff.All together the original Willy Wonka and the Chocolate factory (1971) was an inspiring well thought out movie and blew the remake out of the water. The remake Charlie and the Chocolate Factory (2005) was not so inspiring and left viewers confused on what to think. In order to make a movie great, the plot, acting and theme must all be superior and really work together. In the Original Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory (1971) the quote “All the dreams you’ve ever had, and not just the good ones.
” Are the perfect words to describe this magical yet eerie chocolate factory adventure.