Do Corporate Governance Rules Improve A Companys Ethics Accounting Essay

This thesis intends to measure the two differing systems of corporate administration ordinance adopted in the UK and in Nigeria ; proposing that neither of them better company moralss in world. It will measure its effectivity and failings ; utilizing the ego regulative attack adopted in the UK and the statutory portion regulated attack in Nigeria as a chief focal point, while other legal powers will be referred to for comparative intents. It is the purpose of this paper to show that it is non the existent attack taken which needfully improves ethical behaviors within an organisation but what each single house imbibes in their constructions and procedures as moralss which serves as ordinance towards concern success. This analysis will be assessed by information sourced from a assortment of techniques including informations bite and comparing of operational government regulations of the two provinces vis-a-vis academic literature. Other beginnings of information will be through interviews with legal advisors in this field every bit good as rating of the codification of patterns adopted in a figure of companies which will be used as instance survey.


There has been more consciousness than of all time before on the increasing demand for corporate administration within organisations. As a affair of fact it has become a top precedence legislative issue for most authoritiess around the universe every bit good as top managerial concern for effectual corporate disposal. This is because ill-famed company frauds are linked with bad administration and consequentially economic crisis. Incidentally corporate administration which began around the late 90 ‘s has experienced changeless reappraisals since so on and may hold now reached its extremum where any longer face-lifts will split the bubble and stop up in catastrophic effects.[ 1 ]In response to this, is an appraisal of the two differing attacks adapted in the UK and Nigeria to corporate administration which has non needfully improved ethical behavior in organisations due to short approachs experienced by the systems.

The corporate administration Torahs and ordinances differ from state to state and by the way there is no unvarying criterion acceptable globally.[ 2 ]However there are basic underlining rules which exist as theoretical account counsel for companies to be decently managed and derive the trusts of investors. These include an effectual board ; strong independent non-executive ; institutional investors ; Torahs and ordinances which protect the involvement of stockholders particularly as concerns the minority stockholder ; assignment of independent hearers. Others are specifying the construct of ‘conflicts of involvement ‘ and how it affects the board of managers and other senior direction, set uping an acceptable criterion of fiscal answerability and revelation transparence methods, corporate societal duty or ethical behaviors. However, despite these implicit in rules, the execution of these rules is grounded in the company jurisprudence regulations of each state. For illustration the US and Nigeria operates a ‘comply or countenance ‘ system governed by the Security and Exchange Commission ( SEC ) while the UK operates a ‘comply or explicate ‘ system and is governed by the Financial Reporting Council ( FRC )

While a figure of states have adopted the ego regulative attack to administration which has one of its ain defects as unequal countenances for direction in breach ; the statutory regulated besides have the job of inflexibleness as a ‘one size tantrums all ‘ attack to governance may be unreasonable coupled with execution jobs. There have been a batch of alterations to corporate administration regulations over the old ages in the UK ;[ 3 ]and merely one in Nigeria.[ 4 ]In malice of singular developments and clearly different attacks to execution of the regulations, it appears that a more practical attack will be for each organisation to absorb its ain ethical criterions guided by the company Torahs in topographic point ; i.e. enforced self ordinance.[ 5 ]However, informations bite consequences suggests that both attacks have still recorded some major interruption down,[ 6 ]though the ‘comply or explain ‘ attack adopted in the UK has advanced well and improved company moralss on the whole chiefly because of the civilisation phase at which the society has reached. The state of affairs is non any different in Nigeria which operates a ‘comply or countenance ‘ system either.[ 7 ]

Hence this work will be concluded on the footing that both of these attacks will non be operable unless the socio-economic factors present and the companies separately imbibe the needed standard ethical civilizations. It is proposed that apart from reexamining the single company ‘s Torahs as a unequivocal attack to governance, the function companies by themselves have to play through the power of their fundamental law should non be overlooked.[ 8 ]Awareness of a true ego regulative attack could ensue in a more positive state of affairs for the execution of corporate administration regulations since it will be really hard to enforce ethical ordinances on an single talk less of an organisation. This will in bend promote the uniformity hoped to be achieved by advocators of a joint regulative system across the Earth.

Purposes and Aims of Dissertation

The chief purpose of this research is to foreground the comply or explain and comply or countenance systems have non improved company moralss in entirety and to supply the academic community with an in-depth appraisal of an implemented ego regulative system as a superior attack of transfusing ethical behaviors within an organisation. The experience of the planetary fiscal crisis and the really recent banking dirts in Nigeria are really classical illustrations of unethical traffics within organisations which the administration ordinances in topographic point have non been able precaution.

Specific Issues to be addressed

Is concern moralss merely topical or has it improved concerns by any opportunity?

Has corporate administration improved concern moralss ; statistical illustrations?

Comparison of the function of difficult jurisprudence and soft jurisprudence in corporate administration?

Can a corporation possess and scruples?

The function of company ‘s fundamental law in corporate administration?

Regional facet of corporate administration ; Africa and Europe?

Business challenges ; academic, regional, industrial ; do they hold any common undertakings?

What would be the result of an straight-out mandatary jurisprudence attack to governance?

Should either of the modulating systems be used sing the noteworthy recent yesteryear results?

Are ethical organisations needfully profitable?

Why has the company Torahs non been equal?

Should at that place be dual criterions for private and public companies on moralss?

Preliminary Dissertation Structure

An assessment literature to be structured in five chapters: Chapter I will of course turn to the debut, intent and aim of the research and by and large outline the format the work will take alongside the method. Chapter II examines the corporate administration regulations of ‘comply or explain ‘ attack under the UK system and the ‘comply or countenance ‘ attack under the Nigerian system and the relationship between these regulations and ethical criterions within an organisation. It will besides measure similar work by manner of drumhead to foreground the focal point of this work. Chapter III trades with the development of the regulations and the authorization of each attack in system where it has been adopted. Chapter IV examines the individualism and restrictions of these two attacks and proposing that neither of the systems might be the solution to bettering ethical criterions of an organisation. Chapter V is the decision and recommendations.

Indicative Beginnings

The primary reading will concentrate on diaries and articles of authors on the issue of corporate administration, ordinance, concern ethical behaviors and any literature that might be concerned with positions on the development of corporate administration and or regulative systems. This will besides include any literature on the guidelines for concern moralss where many company codification of patterns stem from.[ 9 ]

Readings from diaries and articles entirely can non turn to all the countries to be covered refering concern moralss. A batch of definitions and cardinal reading specifying cardinal constructs will be used either straight or indirectly from the books of some popular writes of company jurisprudence[ 10 ]

Another set of readings will be concerned with literature from Nigeria on corporate administration and ethical criterions within organisations. This is because this will turn to the peculiar issues confronting administration at that place. This may be backed up with the standard missive format should the available information prove inadequate.[ 11 ]

Research Methodology

The extent to which companies govern themselves is non given much audience ; nevertheless this research will demo that a larger per centum of companies will remain ethical in order to remain in concern. What this means in kernel is that tonss of companies govern themselves by a set of codification of patterns with long term concern wagess in position instead than merely a box clicking attack which the administration systems have put in topographic point making a feeling of dependence and a lower sense of ownership. The truth is that an organisation can easy place with the company Torahs in topographic point and develop its ain set of regulations of behavior which do non merely advance the concern towards a selected market but besides give a feeling of conscientiousness to the proprietors, employees and other stakeholders. To measure this position, information will be obtained from company web sites and farther elucidation will be solicited for through a standard missive will be sent out to different companies ( private or public ) sing being codifications of pattern within their single organisations and turn toing some of the research inquiries mentioned in the cardinal focal point above.

Research Time tabular array

Signal-to-noise ratio




June 2010 to July 2010

Literature Research


July 1- 15, 2010

Sending out Letterss to Companies

July 1- 31, July, 2010

Completion of Chapter I & A ; Receiving Letterss from Companies


August 1- 19 2010

Chapter II & A ; further research


August 20 -30, 2010

Interviews with Legal advisors UK and Nigeria


September – October 2010

Chapter III & A ; IV


October 2010

Chapter V and read of first bill of exchange


November 2010

Submission of complete Thesis