Factors that influenced the change in management accounting Essay

This chapter will reexamine the relevant literature and the apprehension of the traditional function of the direction comptroller. The chapter will get down with an apprehension of the construct of direction accounting. This provides a background for treatment of the traditional function of direction comptroller. Finally, a reappraisal of all the factors that may act upon on the function and promoted the alteration of the function are explored.

2.1 Accounting

‘Accounting is a procedure of identifying, mensurating and pass oning economic information to license informed opinions and determinations by the users of the information ‘

( Wallace, 1997, p.220 )

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!

order now

The history of accounting has progressed in combination with civilization and commercialism. The literature provides grounds that Paciolo in 1494 founded the construct of accounting by publication of ‘Summa de Arithmetica ‘ . He presented accounting in methodical signifier that became a scientific discipline subsequently on.

The definition suggests that accounting is about supplying economic information to others and it relates to the fiscal or economic activities of the administration. Accounting information is identified and measured by the manner of a set of histories or double-entry clerking.

2.1.1 Management accounting

Management accounting is that portion of accounting which provides determination doing information to directors for usage in planning and commanding operations ( Seal at all, 2006 ) . The term of direction accounting is defined by Numberss of writers ( Shank, 1989, Back-Hock, 1992, Nanni at all, 1992 ) in that direction accounting provides information to develop public presentation steps and includes all planning and monitoring in an administration. Simon et al. , ( 1954 ) , cited by Jarvenpaa ( 2007 ) described the function as the traditional function of direction accounting. The function was an operational scorekeeping where accounting information was used to fulfill the administration ‘s coverage duty.

2.1.2 The rise and autumn of direction accounting

The reaching of Johnson and Kaplan ‘s publication Relevant Lost: The rise and autumn of direction accounting ( 1987 ) plays an of import function in the way that learning and research may follow in the close hereafter. J & A ; K states that the diminution of direction accounting began in the 1920s when most of the direction accounting techniques known today were practically developed. Harmonizing to J & A ; K the autumn of direction accounting was chiefly due to the ever-increasing cost of implementing a elaborate and efficient internal merchandise cost system.

J & A ; K argued that direction accounting techniques had non change since 1920s. Up to 1980 ‘s many states enjoyed operating in protective environments. Oversees companies were limited to runing in the domestic market with barriers to communicating, geographical distance and sometimes protected markets ( Drury, 2003 ) . Since 1980s many administrations have changed and adapted new techniques. Organizational alteration had an impact on direction accounting alteration. Cost allotment has been the most debated subject in adult male Air Combat Command. Up to the 1960s criterion costing was promoted by academic and professional administrations and was viewed as the cardinal direction accounting tool in cost control ( Bailey, 2006 ) . Harmonizing to Allott ( 2000 ) “ the station war country was characterised by rational outlooks about human behavior and beliefs in additive advancement, upward mobility and equal chance. ” The 1970 ‘s brought new alterations to direction accounting and standard bing relevancy that began to concentrate more on efficiency. In the big administrations the answerability of standard costing was questioned. Robert S. Kaplan in his Accounting Review argued that cost accounting was developed between 1850 and 1915. He argued that up to 50s large corporations used “ cost oriented techniques ” ( Knortz, 1990 ) but so they started to concentrate more on consumers and their function in a concern.

Due to alterations in fabrication and concern environment, volume based costing is no longer allow because direct labor and stuff disbursals no longer rule merchandise costs. In response to this issue activity based bing system was introduced that brought immense success to Nipponese direction accounting ( Ezzamel, 1994 ) . Each administration must besides see the cultural and societal scene before any changes to the ABC are successful ( Lowry, 1993, Ezzamel, 1994, Otley, 2008 ) .

In drumhead, the alteration of direction accounting outlined by Johnson and Kaplan ( 1987 ) seem to be across direction accounting literature ( Otley, 1985, Noreen, 1987, Drucker, 1990, Ezzamel, 1994, Fry et al. , 1998, Otley,2008 ) . Jonson and Kaplan did raise of import inquiry about direction accounting and helped administrations to re-evaluate the importance of holding an accurate direction accounting system.

2.2 Traditional function

The construct of ‘accountant ‘ was introduced in Italy around the 11th century. At the same clip the first society of comptrollers was set up here in Italy. In 1669 every comptroller must be a member of the college before being allowed to pattern ( Woolf, 1986, p.162 ) .

2.2.1 The typical stereotype

The traditional function of comptroller is frequently called the bean counter stereotype. Holland ( 1973 ) develops a theory on this topic. He classifies people into six classs. The accountant relates to the conventional type giving an overall good feeling, decent, covering with calculations in the organizational and concern field. He linked the work that comptroller does to the type of individual the comptroller is. The close nexus was found by Bougen ( 1994, p.321 ) utilizing assorted personal features and different undertakings. The stereotyped comptroller was defined based on the undertakings carried out.

2.2.2 The Bookkeeper/Traditional Management Accountant

The old inaccurate image of stereotype was seen as quiet, deadening and without original ideas. The survey on this negative image by Beardslee and O’Dowd ( 1962 ) was seen the comptroller as a Victorian bookkeeper disbursement most of the clip at the desk and on a leger without contact with the outside universe.

Simon ( 1954 ) in his surveies classified the function as scorekeeping, job work outing function and attending directing. Harmonizing to Friedman and Lyne ( 1997 ) the scorekeeping focuses on conformity coverage and attending directing focuses on control issues. The jobs work outing function associated with decision-making and providing directors with relevant information.

Feeney and Pierce ( 2007 ) stated that their function did non associate to the concern, had deficiency of creativeness and really limited degree of determinations. Accountants were involved in working with budgeting, discrepancy analysis and traditional accounting. Over the past 30 old ages direction comptroller had a clear but narrow position that direction accounting information could assist to better profitableness. They believed that directors from other sections did non understand the importance of accounting information and all available day of the month they held in the accounting systems. At that clip, direction comptrollers were proved of their function and be able to educate their non-financial directors about the benefits of utilizing this direction comptrollers were traditionally seen as an independent individual who had narrow knowledge how direction accounting information could better profitableness and efficiency of the administration.

Nanni et Al ( 1992 ) point out that traditional direction comptrollers have tended to concentrate on a product-oriented instead than a process-oriented public presentations. There is some grounds that comptrollers have had small involvements in any organizational alterations even they had accomplishments to convey some alterations. For illustration, it was comptrollers who insisted on the execution an activity-based costing system ( Foster and Gupta, 1989 ) or merchandise life-cycle costing system.

2.2.3 ‘Accounting slowdown ‘

Johnson and Kaplan ( 1987 ) criticised direction comptroller for their inability to inventions and this was viewed as an “ accounting slowdown ” .Kaplan ( 1984 ) in his survey about accounting slowdown proposed that accountants “ should develop a research scheme to run into new demands for planning and control information ” . He suggested that there was small invention since 1920. Accounting slowdown demand to be minimized to maintain accounting information relevant to all alterations happening over clip.

2. 3 Pressures for Changes

The literature identifies some relevant factors that impact on the function of direction comptrollers including:

2.3.1 Progresss in Manufacturing and Globalisation

Companies have invested to a great extent in new fabricating engineering such as computing machine aided fabrication ( CAM ) , Computer Aided Design ( CAD ) , and flexible fabrication systems ( FMS ) ( Buggerman and Siagmulder ) The new fabrication engineerings have impacted on traditional pull offing accounting systems and

! “ Consequently it is argued that direction accounting systems have to alter when fabricating systems alteration ”

With regard to merchandise costing and operating expense costs, tracking 1000 ‘s of single merchandises can be overpowering. Traditionally, Labour hours were used as a footing for an overhead allotment. It is possibly less suited as merchandises made through mechanization would be charged an deficient operating expense rate.

The competitory force per unit area on houses and the displacement in many industry sectors from cost led pricing to price-led costing ( Nixon, 1998 ) and globalisation are merely some of the many factors that are act uponing the intensifying outgo on R & A ; D and New Product Development that most companies must now incur.


Pre 1980 ‘s many states enjoyed operating in protective environments. Oversees companies were limited to runing in the domestic market with barriers to communicating, geographical distance and sometimes protected markets ( Drury 2003 )

However fabricating companies were unfastened to break up force per unit area from competition from oversees rivals that offered high quality merchandises at low monetary values. To be successful in competition against these companies they had to progress and follow to alter and happen a competitory arm to vie against universe category fabrication companies.

As a consequence of extremely competitory market, consumers ‘ outlooks, alterations in gustatory sensations and attitudes, companies must now hold the flexibleness to get by with consumer demands for greater assortment and betterments, shorter life rhythms etc.

2.3.3 Progresss in fabricating engineering

Development of direction accounting information engineerings and ERP systems in peculiar have been a cardinal accelerator in I.T. alteration and traditional direction accounting techniques have had to maintain in line and gait with these rapid promotions.

ERP can hold important deductions for direction comptrollers. As noted by Granlund and Malmi ( 2003 ) “ the nexus to direction accounting appears of import since one set of benefits from incorporate systems is assumed to flux from easy and fast entree to operational informations, direction accounting being indispensable for conveying such informations in a managerial relevant and useable signifier ” . Besides when major graduated table alterations sing information systems occur, logic of accounting becomes exposed to rating and possible alterations.

As ERP is a wholly incorporate information system it merges together all informations from fabricating section to gross revenues division and the integrated information flows instantly through the system ( ) . As a effect of this integrating comptrollers have had to larn to work with this new system, and to look at the concern as a procedure instead than in divisions which has led to more team work and greater cross functional communicating and co-operation.

On the other manus there is grounds proposing the accounting professionals are developing a broader function for themselves. Accountants are going less in charge of informations assemblage and more informations reading and confer withing sort of work. ERP has eliminated several figure scranching assignments as it ‘s already done by the system therefore go forthing more clip for comptrollers to spread out their capablenesss. Their function can be enhanced by going advisers and internal advisers to other directors.

With the execution and running of ERP systems comptrollers have gained a more active function in the care and direction of the IT country and gnawing into activities and duties typical of the I.T. country. Caglio ( 2003 ) states that “ As a effect of the presentation of ERP systems, comptrollers have experienced a phenomenon of Hybridization deducing from their set of patterns and legitimized competences ”

2.3.4 Changes in administration construction

Changes in fabrication engineering, globalization and ferocious competition have lead to alterations in the construction of the administration. Companies have focus on retrenchment, detain pealing direction activities and outsourcing support services. Technology progresss in flexible fabrication robotics automated production and computerised technology and planning are impacting the markets raising the quality of merchandises and services while take downing and extinguishing stock degrees ( Baily 2006 )


Chapter 3

3.1 Change is a contextual procedure

Nathan birnbaums and Vaivio ( 2001 ) described alteration as a complex and contextual procedure. They introduced three positions on alteration. The first position explores the thought that what sometimes appears to be alteration, may non really be the alteration ( DCU thesis ) . Change could be an semblance or sort of organisational mirage and frequently can be seen as positive phenomenon. But sometimes direction accounting alteration could take to significant jobs such as unanticipated struggle ( Malmi, 1997 ; Kasurinen, 1999 ; Granlund, 2001 ) . The 2nd position provides a argument about the logic of alteration. Any alterations including direction accounting alteration is non planned, but is viewed as a portion of world and impersonal activity. The concluding position point out that direction accounting can be viewed as phenomenon. Therefore alteration may be presented as a centrally goaded attempt where the direction plays an of import function.

For illustration in the instance of amalgamations and acquisitions happening, new regulations will be introduced and/or modified. This can go on intentionally or unconsciously. Deliberate alterations could happen due to resistance within the acquired administration ( Burns and Scapens 2000 ) Changes may be unconscious when regulations are merely misunderstood or are inappropriate to the fortunes.

3.2 Management accounting alteration

Management accounting alteration has become an progressively popular focal point for research in direction accounting in 1990s due to execution of activity-based costing ( Innes and Mitchell, 1990 ) , activity-based cost direction ( Friedman and Lyne, 1995 ) , life rhythm costing ( Shields and Young, 1991 ) and mark costing ( e.g. Dutton and Ferguson, 1996 ) .

Recent research has debated whether direction accounting has changed, has non changed or should be changed. ( Burns and Scapens 2000 ) Whether direction accounting has changed or non, that the environment in which direction comptrollers operate surely has changed with progresss in information engineering, alteration in administration construction and stiffer competitory markets.

The apprehension of direction accounting alteration constitutes much more than the choice of what may be perceived as being optimum accounting systems and techniques, followed by a proficient procedure of execution. ( Burns et al book ) Selecting and utilizing the right direction accounting techniques and the proficient facets of public presentation are of import, but there are besides behavioral and cultural issues to be understood in relation to alter execution and alteration direction. The chief focal point on direction accounting alteration is on understanding the procedures involved in the execution of direction accounting alteration and the complexnesss of, and troubles involved in, altering direction accounting systems, techniques and functions.

Burns ( 1999 ) suggest that many administrations have modus operandis in topographic point and new alterations introduced will take to the alteration of the nature of the administration. In the early 1980s a undertaking, called the Production Cost Control Project was set up to better the flow of acc info in Omega Plc. The undertaking had failed because the operating directors saw the concern in footings of producing-based significances and modus operandis. The divisional comptrollers viewed the concern as fiscal term and regarded PCCP as a agency of presenting accounting-based modus operandis.

Sulaiman and Mitchell ( 2005 ) carried out survey on direction accounting alteration in Malayan fabrication companies. After garnering all information a four types of alteration had occurred. The two types occurred due to new technique debut and two concerned bing direction accounting alteration. The research found that direction comptroller classified the degree of direction accounting alteration into five generalized constituents.

3.3 Institutional theory

3.3.1 Institution

Institutional theory is a theoretical model that became more relevant in research of direction accounting alteration. In accepting this theory there is no universally agreed definition of an establishment. Scott ( 1995 ) describes “ instutions are societal constructions that have attained a high grade of resiliency ” Burns and Scapens ( 19990 defined establishment as a manner of action of expectedness which is surrounded in the wonts of a group of people.

3.3.2 Institutional model as a regulations and modus operandis construct

Development of the model began by looking at the manner in which order is achieved through regulations and modus operandis. The model perceive direction accounting to be a regulations and modus operandis constituted by established wonts. ( Kim Soin, 2002 ) . Hodgson ( 1993 ) defined wonts as ‘self-actualizing temperaments or inclinations to prosecute in antecedently adopted signifier of action ‘ . Habit is a personal action where modus operandis involve group of people as constituents of establishment. Routines play an of import function in an administration in which direction accounting was viewed as a regulation construct where direction comptroller performed everyday undertakings. Rules may be became implemented through the constitution of modus operandis and frailty versa. Therefore the reproduction of functions and modus operandi will prevail over clip and the modus operandis of direction comptrollers may be changed. The procedure of alteration may develop new modus operandis which over clip could be institutionalised.

In the administration modus operandis can be adapted really rapidly over the clip. Human behavior in the administration is based on reiterating actions to follow with regulations and modus operandis as they provide an organizational memory and stand for the footing for the development of the behavior ( Kim Soin, 2002 ) . Guerreiro, R at Al ( 2006 ) used wont, modus operandis and establishments to exemplify how accounting patterns can turn from wont to establishments through modus operandis. They concluded that ‘all establishments are structured on the footing of take-for-granted wonts and modus operandis ‘ , win during a certain period and are realised in a signifier of normative regulations.

3.3.3 ‘Taken for granted ‘

Harmonizing to Scapens ( 2006 ) administrations react more easy to alterations than persons as they removed signifier every twenty-four hours activities in some manner. He observed that over clip, direction accounting can incorporate a construction that shows the manner administrations believing and moving – which is widely taken for granted. Management comptrollers were viewed as everyday characteristics in the administration and they merely taken for granted as the manner things are.

Some researches of institutionalism criticised the model as it overplays its accent on stability at the disbursal of concentrating on institutional alteration. Quattrone and Hopper ( 2001 ) explained how direction accounting can be influenced by an administration or by persons. Individuality argues that an administration alterations when single actions modify the administration. They introduced the construct of ‘drift ‘ for buildings of accounting alteration. The writers replaced the word ‘change ‘ with universe ‘drift ‘ . Quattrone and Hopper ( 2001 ) take impetus as to stand for accounting alteration as “ uncomplete efforts at organizing ” and underscore that human elements that situate accounting alteration is non a seaport to the alteration. They argued that accounting alteration was besides promoted by proficient and inscribed elements.

In a recent survey of alteration in direction accounting Busco at all ( 2007 ) organised the impression of alteration within cardinal dimensions. The cardinal dimensions were evaluated in footings of the ratio and signifiers of alteration every bit good as rating over infinite and clip of alteration. They carried out a instance survey to look into those cardinal dimensions in the Middle-East Gas and Oil Company ( MEGOC ) as a big corporation operating in the oil and gas industry. They found that alteration can merely go on due to incompleteness that exists within an administration. Busco at all ( 2007 ) concluded that ‘management accounting alteration is a theoretical infinite which, perchance more than many others in direction and organisational surveies, intersects and interacts with the broader knowledge country of the societal scientific disciplines, sociology and doctrine of cognition and scientific discipline and engineering surveies ‘


Chapter 4

4.1 Management comptroller as intercrossed comptroller

The term intercrossed comptroller emerged in the literature from about 1995 as its function was focused on merchandise watercourse. Burns and Baldvinsdottir ( 2005 ) studied a construct of new function of direction comptroller as ‘hybrid comptroller ‘ by analyzing a transnational pharmaceutical company in the fabrication division. Their survey found that the figure of intercrossed comptrollers increase with development of squad relationship constructing while everyday accounting function vanishing. Two types of intercrossed comptroller were found from their survey: finance director and finance analyst were the finance director was involved in strategic issues and the finance analyst was involved with twenty-four hours to twenty-four hours activities. Harmonizing to Miller et Al ( 2007 ) loanblend is defined as “ new phenomena produced out of two or more elements usually found individually ” . The treatment in the literature around ‘hybrid comptroller ‘ has developed in ‘business spouse ‘ way.

4.2 Business spouse function

It has been noted in the literature that direction comptroller have become more and more involved in concern procedures ( Sathe, 1982, Keating and Joblonsky ) and have demonstrated a strong concern apprehension ( Feeney, 2007, Burns at all, 1999 ) . Hopper ( 1980 ) found that chief undertaking of comptrollers was to move in a service function instead than a bookkeeper. He found that bulk described their traditional knowledge as the service function and merely few called themselves as the bookkeeper and preferred the direction accounting undertakings to be centralised. Grnalund and Lukka ( 1998 ) presented the transmutation from bean counter to business-orientated direction accountant place. The transmutation occurred with the increasing decentalisation of the direction accounting map. They concluded that those two functions are really different and a individual can non move in both functions. Some grounds emerging in the literature that transmutation of direction comptrollers to concern spouse started at the top by the concern and net income Centre directors became more depended on comptrollers. Directors used their aid as the counsel to run their concern ( Siegel, 2003 ) and they expect from comptrollers a better concern apprehension and more flexibleness ( Pierce and O’Dea, 2003 ) .

Nathan birnbaums and Baldvinsdottir ( 2005 ) concluded that it is necessary for direction comptrollers to hold a wide scope of concern accomplishments with their basic proficient accomplishments.

4.3 Professional accomplishments of direction comptroller ( subheading needed )

As procedures have changed and accounting has adapted over clip to run into the demands of of all time altering concern, direction comptrollers have been required to alter their accomplishments. ( Fleming 1999 ) They are projected to be frontward believing concern predictor s who add value to the entity and non merely foregrounding whether the marks have been met ( Burns and Yazdifar ) Traditionally direction comptrollers spent clip on fixing standardised studies. Today the displacement has moved towards analysing, construing and supplying information for determination devising intents. ( Roberta et al 2009 ) These accomplishments include traditional every bit good as soft accomplishments that these direction comptrollers posses in order to lend positively to the undertakings that are acquired to execute as portion of their function ( Jones and Abraham 2007 ) A recent survey by Freeny and Pierce 2007 looked at direction comptroller accomplishments and asked both directors and direction comptrollers to rank accomplishments in order of sensed importance.

Ethical motives and honestness were rated extremely by both parties. “ Managers value the indifferent and nonsubjective position offered by direction accountants- the fiscal Numberss can non afford to be skewed in favour of a certain point of view ” Accuracy is besides important. A simple mistake in computation could amount to 1000000s of Euros, which could take to a incorrect determination ( Siegal 2000 ) As portion of Management comptrollers function meeting towards intercrossed comptrollers as concern spouses, honestness is good but they have to take into history a spot of bull on ( Freeny and Pierce 2007 ) and treat the commercial cognition required on their behalf to acquire the occupation done.

For many concerns, critical thought, job resolution and analytical accomplishments are indispensable tools. It is an of import accomplishment of direction comptrollers to believe critically and to be good at job work outing. They need to be able to step back and expression at something outside of the box ( Siegal 2000 )

“ people can be a ace at spreadsheets, can pull strings informations efficaciously but can they calculate out whether the information in forepart of them is moderately or realistic ” ( Freeny and Pierce 2007 )

Histories have to be able to believe logically in a concern puting. They ca n’t merely larn off and memorise what to make in different state of affairss. Creativity is besides of import, to be able to step aside and demo some invention and thoughts to jobs.

In the survey by Freeny and Pierce direction comptroller ‘s existent evaluations in relation to interpersonal/ leading and communicating accomplishment set fell below director ‘s outlooks. These are classed as cardinal accomplishments and a necessary to hold the ability to take on a complex topic and turn it into easy apprehensible linguistic communication and be able to explicate it to directors and other non comptrollers. “ you guys can be masterminds with your spreadsheets but there is n’t that many of you that can sit down at the meeting and portion information. A cardinal duty in roll uping studies for usage is that the input is based from other forces throughout the organisation. Good forces accomplishments are needed to near these directors and petition information. Problems could originate where directors believe direction comptrollers can set their marks and cause jobs. This requires significant interpersonal accomplishments to shut the communicating spread.

It is apparent that direction comptrollers must fix and fit themselves for their new function in line with altering concern demands. Professional accounting organic structures must update and overhaul their preparation and instruction course of study to vouch that today ‘s direction comptrollers can get by with new information engineering systems, scheme and concern spouse function. ( Burns and Yazdifar )

As many of the new accounting functions do non needfully necessitate a direction comptroller there is a menace posed to the profession. For illustration if an technology house is seeking for a new concern director they might seek applied scientists who encompass concern cognition with an accountant making instead than a to the full qualified direction comptroller. To battle this menace accounting pedagogues should develop course of studies that are less dominated by traditional direction patterns and concentrate on direction accounting in a modern visible radiation and equip pupils with the accomplishments necessary and utile to supply a value-added service.

Carcello et Al ( 1991 ) conducted a study of comparing pupil outlooks to that of accounting professionals expectancies. Students included in the sample were within six months of graduating and professional comptrollers were in the work topographic point for 1.5 old ages to 3.5 old ages. Four inquiries of the study peaceably related to accomplishments indispensable as a practicing comptroller. ( A ) Technical Knowledge, ( B ) C computing machine Skills, ( C ) Verbal and Written Communication accomplishments, ( D ) Interpersonal accomplishments.

Respondents had to rank the accomplishments on a five point graduated table. The consequences of the study showed that professionals and pupils had similar positions as to the importance of proficient cognition and computing machine accomplishments. Students perceived communicating accomplishments and interpersonal accomplishments as more of import than professionals. Carcello et Al ( 1991 ) concluded that this is a positive consequence as both communicating and interpersonal accomplishments are indispensable properties of the accounting profession.

Oswick et Al ( 1994 ) conducted a study on the perceptual experience of public accounting accomplishments held by uk pupils with accounting and non accounting calling aspirations. The perceptual experience of a traditional comptroller being dull and missing in societal accomplishments is detained with non accountant pupils. In Oswick ‘s survey these non accounting pupils perceived empathy and societal manners as less of import accomplishments necessary than accounting pupils. Interpersonal accomplishments were besides rated lowly as perceived of import by pupils non interested in accounting. Students interested in accounting did put a higher weighting on interpersonal accomplishments and view the accounting profession as a more synergistic and societal profession.

From the studies conducted on accomplishments required by comptrollers it is apparent that there has been as increased weighting on the soft accomplishments acquired by direction comptroller. Such grounds had had deductions for accounting pedagogues.

It is necessary to enable pupils and for module to stay abreast of the alterations taking topographic point in the profession and to place cardinal Accounting Skills needed for success. ( Russell et al 1999 )

Chapter 5 Methodology

5.1 Introduction

The intent of this chapter is to lucubrate on the research methodological analysis that was used in this thesis. The beginning of this chapter refers to the aim of the research and is followed by the procedure of choosing the research method. This chapter besides considers the restrictions of the chosen research method.

5.2 Objective

As outlined in the debut chapter the chief intent of this thesis is to look into the alteration of direction comptrollers over clip. The research worker wishes to place the traditional function of direction comptrollers and comparison to the modern function of direction comptroller. The writers besides seek to research the factors that promoted the alteration.

A figure of researches have already been carried out on “ concern spouse ” or “ intercrossed ” accountant function and this has resulted a important handiness of information sing this country. However, there is a deficiency of scrutiny in some countries that the research will research.

5.3 Chosen methodological analysis

In order to accomplish the research objectives it is necessary to take an appropriate research attack. Tsetsekos ( 1993 ) outlined that the research methodological analysis is really of import as it “ specifies the information demands for the successful completion of a research undertaking ” . This thesis is based on a secondary research that includes a critical reappraisal of anterior literature. Secondary information consists of both quantitative and qualitative informations.

5.3.1 Secondary Data – Literature reappraisal

A comprehensive reappraisal of the literature was conducted in chapter one, two and three. Literature reappraisal helps the reader to develop a good apprehension of the chosen country and the tendencies that have emerged ( Saunders et Al, 2007 ) and set up what is ready known and unknown about the survey ( Patton, 2002 ) . For this thesis the chief literature reappraisal is done at the beginning of the research survey and the reappraisal was on-going, go oning until a decision was finalized. Initially the literature reappraisal focused on direction accounting alteration and the altering function of direction comptrollers.

It is a really of import portion of the research procedure and it is imperative that secondary informations used are accurate, relevant and sufficient ( Zikmund, 1991 ) . Secondary informations is normally available from both the original beginning and from beginnings that summarize informations collected by others, and might be available at no cost to the populace as the informations already exists. It can take a broad assortment of signifiers, as ushers to organic structures of gathered informations make clear ( Miller, 1991 ) . The literature observed was chiefly sourced from concern and accounting databases by reexamining professional diaries and magazines articles and articles in referred academic diaries.

The undermentioned academic diaries provided a rich beginning of literature:

British Accounting Review

European Accounting Review

International Journal of Accounting Information Systems

Journal of Accounting and Organisational Change

Management Accounting Research

These beginnings were utile and dependable in obtaining articles from published equal reviewed articles from academic diaries and magazines.

In add-on library research was besides conducted. This consisted of reexamining direction accounting books ; past MBS Accounting theses and internet research of relevant web sites were examined in order to derive sufficient cognition of the country.

5.3.2 Qualitative Data

Saunders ( 2007 ) described qualitative informations as all non-numeric informations that can be a merchandise of all research schemes. Qualitative research helps develop apprehension of the research subject, coercing the research worker to set to one side his or her ain mentality. It considered to be inductive in nature, allowing the research worker to develop ain perceptual experiences and theory from the information. Russell and Gregory ( 2003 ) identified in the literature 40 attacks that can be used to roll up qualitative informations.

The chief aim of qualitative research is to make a methodological analysis for nearing, understanding, analyzing and explicating direction phenomena at a societal or company degree ( Delatter et al 2009 ) . Data is analyzed deductively. The writers do non put out to turn out or confute a theory they have prior to the survey. The theory emerges as a piece of art that has non yet been created instead than a mystifier where the image is already known. Events are observed in their natural scene. Concerned with process- Qualitative research workers are concerned with procedure instead than simple results.

5.3.3 Quantitative Data

Quantitative informations consist all numerical informations that could be quantified to run into the research aim. A quantitative attack is one where the writers undertake statistical proving on categorical and quantifiable informations to prove the relationship between variables. The aim of quantitative research is to develop and use mathematical theoretical accounts, diagrams theories and hypotheses taking to phenomena in their ain natural scene ( Sauders et al. , 2003 )

5.4 Research Restrictions

5.4.1 Accuracy and dependability of informations

It is of import to observe that every research has some restrictions. Secondary informations representation of the analysis in which it was used in a broad scope of possible mistakes and biasness. As outlined before secondary informations should be accurate, valid, dependable and appropriate. Secondary informations must accurately reflect what was analyzing and the true population parametric quantity. Secondary information is more presentable in a tabular format that does non reflect the analyst ‘s current survey. The writers used equal reviewed articles from academic diaries and published professional diaries and magazines, imparting to dependability and creditability of the secondary informations analyzed for the intent of this research paper.

5.4.2 Time slowdown

There is ever a clip slowdown between the information is gathered and the twelvemonth of its publication. A 2009 publication is improbable consist informations gathered at the earlier informations such as 2008. Sometimes the clip slowdown can be even longer which can falsify the information ‘s relevance to modern times and belie the true significance of the information. The information of publish beginnings might be out of day of the month at the clip of publication particularly when the research worker want to do usage of statistics.

5.4.3 Beginning prejudice

The writers have to be witting of biasness when they are reexamining secondary beginnings of information. They have to be cognizant of grounds or motivations for hankering to show a more optimistic or pessimistic consequences in their research. They have to be sensitive of and be unfastened to the thought that informations may hold been over overdone of distorted.

5.5 Chapter Summary

This chapter describes the research attack used by the writers, including the research aims, literature reappraisal and subsequent chapters. Besides provided are research restrictions of secondary informations and the consciousness of the writers of these restrictions.