Is income smoothing a good thing? Essay

Income smoothing is an active use of net incomes toward a preset mark. It involves taking stairss to cut down and hive away net incomes during the good old ages and postpone them for usage during the business-downturn old ages, taking volatility in net incomes ( Healy & A ; Wahien, 1999 ) . The application of income smoothing can besides be referred to as net incomes direction or originative accounting.Regulatory model provides statute laws which govern fiscal coverage ( i.e. The Companies Act 2006 ) and Accounting criterions, which are elaborate regulations regulating the accounting intervention of minutess, and other points shown in the statements. Income smoothing though really normally used, is non an recognized pattern and must be looked out for by hearers.

In the 1960 ‘s the fiscal sector of the UK economic system lost assurance in the accounting profession, as internationally known UK based companies were seen to print fiscal informations that was materially wrong. There were two large dirts, the first being the General electric company ( GEC ) coup d’etat of AEI. Pre coup d’etat histories prepared declared net income prognosiss of ?10 million differing materially from the station coup d’etat histories, which showed a loss of ?4.5 million. These differences arose from differences in ‘judgement ‘ i.e. the new managers took a different position to the value of stock.

We Will Write a Custom Essay about Is income smoothing a good thing? Essay
For You For Only $13.90/page!

order now

The second was Pergamon Press Ltd which showed a net income of ?2million, where an independent probe by Price Waterhouse suggested net incomes should be lowered by 75 % because of a failure to cut down certain stock at the lower of cost and cyberspace realisable value. These two existent life illustrations highlighted aggressive net incomes direction and how easy mislead stakeholders were.It is of import to guarantee histories give a ‘true and just position ‘ as there are many different stakeholders.

Investors need to cognize how profitable/stable a company is before puting. Lenders and Bankss need to be certain the company will be able to refund loans, so necessitate to be able to swear reported figures. Despite the demand for histories to fulfill stakeholder demands, the economic ruin has increased force per unit areas on every dimension, so direction changing feelings about their house ‘s concern public presentation has increased. The Auditing Practices Board ( APB ) ( 2001 ) stated ‘when economic conditions become hard, the likeliness of aggressive net incomes direction and misdirecting fiscal coverage additions. ‘ An of import facet of fiscal coverage is showing information about a company ‘s public presentation shown by steps of net incomes and their constituents ( Kirschenheiter & A ; Melumad, 2002 ) . Income smoothing influences information sing the company ‘s public presentation.

The concluding figures published need to be utile to the readers of the fiscal statements. This relates to the dependability of the histories. Dependability is the quality of information that assures information is moderately free from mistake and prejudice and represents what it seeks out to stand for. ( Kirschenheiter and Melumad, 1997:50 ) . When smoothing happens, the information may non be dependable or free from prejudice, once more non being of usage to the stakeholders. Another accounting policy that needs to be followed when fixing histories is relevancy.Income smoothing can happen in many different ways, with book entries being used to pull strings net incomes. These entries stretch accounting rules to their bound and compromise the unity of any information based on such entries.

Ellis and Williams ( 1993:169 ) province net incomes are non a dependable step of a company ‘s public presentation as companies adjust net incomes to accommodate their ain intents by utilizing commissariats. The most common country where smoothing is applied is depreciation. Companies can alter the method of deprecation and change the utile lives of fixed assets.Another common country unfastened to use is stock rating which was made clear in the instance of Pergamon Press Ltd ( mentioned above ) . The ‘allocation ‘ book entry groups together the assignment of costs of depreciable assets to fabricate stock lists, period disbursals, and sums reported on twelvemonth terminal balance sheets. Costss of stock lists and supplies are assigned to period disbursals and shutting stock lists ( Thomas, 1975 ) . The ‘matching ‘ book entry trades with whether a dealing should be recorded during the current period or the following departure it down to managerial determination instead than an accounting pick.

( Wolk, Francis and Tearney, 1992 ) .There are many grounds for income smoothing, which can be associated with the size of the company and the divergence from existent net incomes from prognosiss. Reasons could include guaranting the endurance of the administration, whilst others could be due to the being of fillip inducement strategies, where directors have more incentive to smooth net incomes to project a better than expected degree of public presentation, in order to derive a fillip themselves. In relation to this, smoothing may increase a director ‘s compensation if tied to reported net incomes ( Wild et al. 2001 ) . Another ground for smoothing income is to take down a company ‘s revenue enhancement load ( Getschow 1986 ) .

If net incomes are projected as low, the sum to be paid to the revenue enhancement office will accordingly be lower. Management demand to guarantee smoothing is done for the good of the administration ( i.e. its endurance ) and does non endanger minority stakeholders or employees. If direction want to make certain ends to the harm of the outside stakeholders, it could be perceived as self good, unethical and deceitful ( Chong, 2006 ) . An illustration could be if a procedure is implemented to run into marks due to hapless direction.

If direction systematically act self beneficially, stockholders and relevant other stakeholders will lose religion in the administration and unwanted media and investor attending could happen.Frequently, it is really hard for users of the histories to be able to state if income smoothing has occurred, as they rely on the hearer ‘s study and assume all accounting criterions and patterns have been put into topographic point and followed. Many times nevertheless, income smoothing has occurred in flexibleness of the by and large accepted accounting rules ( GAAP ) and with the many possible readings of some of the rules put frontward.

Getschow ( 1986 ) , stated the Union Carbide Corporation increased their first one-fourth net income ( without adding hard currency ) by using more broad accounting methods for depreciation, investing revenue enhancement credits and involvement cost incurred during building. This was referred to as ‘Accounting thaumaturgy ‘ as it was done within the regulations of GAAP. Yoon and Miller 2002 argue directors willfully manipulate reported net incomes to suit their ain purposes by choosing certain accounting policies, altering accounting estimations and pull stringsing accumulations.

As this is all done within GAAP, a big duty lies with the hearers who must give an independent sentiment on whether managers give a ‘true and just position ‘ and recognize these ‘magic fast ones ‘ normally used, increasing the subjectiveness of fiscal statements. The APB ( 2001 ) highlights the demand for hearers to move with greater professional agnosticism, and understand the force per unit areas on managers and direction to present specific degrees of net incomes. Understanding the attacks and frequence could ease the designation of internal participants of an administration. ( Nelson, Elliot & A ; Tarpley, 2003 ) .As income smoothing/ originative accounting is perceived as fallacious pattern, ways to forestall it should be considered. An illustration of this can affect necessitating regular reappraisals, so gains/losses are identified each twelvemonth as they occur, instead than looking in entire in the twelvemonth of disposal.Overall, the nature of fiscal describing involves bring forthing concluding histories demoing the current place of a given company. Users of the histories ( including investors, loaners, clients etc ) realise the importance of public presentation rating and recognize the higher the degrees of net incomes, the better the company is making.

Keeping investor ‘s assurance high is highly of import and the demand to keep that is even higher. Income smoothing can be bad every bit good as a good thing. Good income smoothing occurs when direction make a stable fiscal public presentation by acceptable and voluntary concern determinations ( Chong, 2006 ) A small window dressing may be harmless so long as it does non harm any of the stakeholders. Bad income smoothing occurs when direction creates unreal accounting entries or stretches estimations beyond sensible bounds ( Parfet, 2000 ) . In many state of affairss the line between good and bad income smoothing is really shaded. Management demand to take into history state of affairss that may alter and reexamine options based on the current and future concern legal environment.

The cardinal component here, to guarantee income smoothing remains ‘good ‘ , is to guarantee actions are for the benefit of the company, ( its stakeholders ) , and non an single director or a specific stakeholder group, and that legal and ethical evidences are kept within.Finally, accounting ordinance is set out to forestall deceitful and unethical behavior, nevertheless, book maintaining entries are leting the smoothing of income within all evidences of the GAAP, so hearers need to be excessively sceptic. Despite income smoothing being labelled as a negative phenomenon, direction will go on to smooth income, with the cognition that it may harm investors, so long as they believe they will non acquire caught or it will be of benefit to them.


Chong, G. , ( 2006 ) . Is income smoothing ethical? Journal of Corporate Accounting. 18 41-44Elliott, B. , Elliot, J.

, ( 2009 ) . Fiscal Accounting and Reporting. 13th Edition Harlow: Pearson Education Ltd.Ellis, J. , Williams, D. , ( 1993 ) Corporate scheme and fiscal analysis. London: Pitman Publishing.Getschow, G.

, ( 1986 ) . Paper net incomes. In: the accounting sampling station. 4th Edition. New York: McGraw Hill.Healy, P. M.

, & A ; Wahien, J. M. ( 1999 ) .

A reappraisal of the net incomes direction literature and its deductions for standard scene. Accounting Horizons. 13 365-383.Kirschenheiter, M. , Melumad, N.D. , ( 2002 ) . Can ‘big bath ‘ and net incomes smoothing co exist as equilibrium fiscal coverage schemes? Journal of Accounting Research.

40 ( 3 ) , 761-797.Kirschenheiter, M. , Melumad, N.D. , ( 2002 ) . Net incomes Quality and smoothing.

Working paper. Draft: June 2002Nelson, M. W. , Elliot, J. A.

, & A ; Tarpley, R. L. ( 2003 ) . How are net incomes managed? Examples from hearers.

Accounting Horizons, 17 17-26.Parfet, W. ( 2000 ) . Accounting subjectiveness and net incomes direction: A preparer ‘s position. Accounting Horizons, 14 481-488.The Auditing Practices Board. ( 2001 ) . Aggressive Net incomes direction.

[ on-line ] Available from: & lt ; & gt ; [ Accessed 3rd April 2010 ]Thomas, A.

L. , ( 1975 ) . The allotment of false belief and fiscal analysis. Fiscal Analyst Journal. 1 ( 5 ) , 37-41Wild, J.J. , Bernstein, L.A.

, Subramanyam. , K.R. , ( 2001 ) . Fiscal Statement Analysis.

7th Edition. New York: McGraw -Hill Higher Education.Wolk, H.L.

, Francis, J.R. , Tearney, M.G. , ( 1992 ) .

Accounting theory – A conceptual and institutional attack. 3rd Edition. Buckeye state: South Western Publishing.

Yoon, S.S. , Miller, G.A.

, ( 2002 ) Cash from operations and net incomes direction in Korea. The international diary of Accounting. 37 ( 4 ) , 395-412.