Outsourcing America’s Future Essay

Thesis Statement

Outsourcing is an economic disadvantage that puts the long-run fight of the U.S. economic system at hazard.


Offshore outsourcing is an progressively popular phenomenon that can be viewed as another signifier of international free trade. The construct of outsourcing roots from the thought of comparative advantage which suggests that persons, houses and states are better at bring forthing certain goods and services and therefore must concentrate on bring forthing those over others.

This signifier of trade allows states to specialise in bring forthing narrower scopes of goods, therefore giving them greater efficiencies of large-scale production. While we can turn out that outsourcing has had a positive affect on short term economic growing, the long term effects are yet unknown and may turn out destructive. By outsourcing occupations of extremely skilled workers, cognition is inescapably transferred to developing economic systems.

This spillover creates bunchs of growing that have the capableness of viing with U.S. corporations in future old ages. This paper will concentrate on the effects outsourcing imposes on concern costs, returns to scale, American instruction, and concern cognition. Will U.S.

corporations truly salvage money in the long tally by reassigning work overseas?


Outsourcing has provided organic growing to United States corporations and has enabled them to cut down costs and vie more efficaciously in planetary markets. While this proliferation of outsourcing has been good to short term growing, it may besides be fade outing the competitory advantage that the state has enjoyed in the past century. Through altering the historical theoretical account of economic systems of graduated table, the intangible effects and concealed costs of outsourcing will weigh to a great extent on the U.S. economic system in future old ages. The competitory advantage of high engineering is at hazard, and the spillover will enable developing states to vie straight with the United States.Many economic experts view outsourcing as merely a new signifier of international free trade.

More trade goods are tradable than were tradable in the yesteryear, which can be viewed as either a good or bad thing. The general premise of the American populace is that occupations, money, accomplishments, and experience are being exported to foreign states, and the people in these foreign states are doing fiscal, socio-economic and development advancement while the U.S. economic system is stagnated.

Consumers are accustomed to the fact that manufactured goods are produced abroad and imported to the U.S. , nevertheless now consumers must accept the fact that services are besides being produced overseas. It appears that more and more U.S. companies are experimenting with outsourcing and offshoring their labour and services with the feeling that they are take downing their operating costs. This experimentation has transformed the U.S.

into a service oriented state with a trade shortage that continues to turn ensuing in more occupations being lost alternatively of being created. The morale of U.S. workers has been destroyed and a sense of fright has been injected into many Americans, including our extremely skilled professionals. Although unrealistic at this point in clip, many believe the addition use of outsourcing can lend to the U.S. going a 3rd universe state. Are we endangering our place in the universe as a lead economic power?The most noteworthy outsourced divisions within a company have been client support/call centres, accounting, human resources and fabrication.

In today ‘s society at that place has been a greater menace imposed on the American engineering industry, such as information engineering and applied scientists. In add-on, other extremely skilled workers in R & A ; D, pharmaceutical, and fiscal places have been impacted every bit good. Our extremely skilled workers are losing their occupations to companies overseas because of the lower labour costs incurred. As can be expected, most American workers are non excessively lament on the thought of outsourcing. For illustration, a package applied scientist at Microsoft is likely non likely to leap up and down at the idea of losing his occupation to a worker in India, who is willing to make the occupation for less than half the wage. By 2015, it is predicted that every bit many as 3.

3 million white-collar occupations and $ 136 billion in rewards will go forth the U.S. In add-on to employee dissatisfaction, several other hazards occur as a consequence of outsourcing that consequence the overall economic system.

Why Outsource?

Outsourcing frequently refers to the deputation of non-core operations or occupations from internal production to an external entity specialising in the direction of that operation. The determination to outsource is frequently made in the involvement of take downing house costs, airting or conserving energy directed at the competences of a peculiar concern, or to do more efficient usage of world-wide labour, capital, engineering and resources.

Though frequently used interchangeably, outsourcing differs from offshoring in that outsourcing is comparative to the restructuring of the house while offshoring is comparative to the state. Basically, outsourcing is a term relation to the organisation of labour within and between societies. Offshoring, besides known as international outsourcing, can happen when a section of a nationally located production procedure gets moved offshore – possibly still under the control of a national house, or sold off to a different house runing overseas. These constructs have become a popular tendency among many U.S. companies and at times raise controversial arguments.The individual most of import tactical ground for outsourcing is to cut down or command operating costs and increase net incomes.

Access to an outside supplier ‘s lower cost construction is one of the most compelling short-run benefits of outsourcing. Developing states offer the endowments of a college-educated work force at a fraction of U.S.

wages. Partnering with an organisation with first capablenesss can offer entree to new engineering, tools and techniques that the organisation may non presently possess ; more structured methodological analysiss, processs and certification, and a competitory advantage through expanded accomplishments. Competing corporations are outsourcing operations offshore to hold the cost advantages over the market and to liberate up direction resources. Although outsourcing has achieved cost nest eggs and has been used to come in cardinal foreign markets, these benefits may non outweigh the long-run impacts on U.S. industries and the economic system.

Economies of Scale

When states trade with each other one of their chief ends is to accomplish economic systems of graduated table in production. Alternatively of the U.

S. seeking to bring forth everything domestically they may make up one’s mind to specialise in bring forthing merely certain types of goods or services at a larger graduated table with the purpose to take down costs. The U.

S. will export those goods which formulate a comparative advantage and import ( outsource ) those goods with lower labour costs. The basic expression associated with economic systems of graduated table is:AC = F/Q + degree CelsiusWhere AC is the mean cost per unit produced, F is fixed costs, Q is the figure of units produced, and degree Celsius is the fringy cost per unit. The fixed costs represent the operating expense that is independent of production, normally including rent, public-service corporations, some forces, etc. The fringy cost, degree Celsius, histories for all costs accrued during the industry of a individual unit, normally including natural stuff, labour, etc.

Labor may account for a important part of the fringy costs, and as such, companies seek to cut down this outgo. By traveling operations overseas, the house may be able to use cheaper labour and cut down fringy costs per unit produced. Property, substructure, and even revenue enhancements may be less overseas and supply inducement for outsourcing operations. We can easy account for these touchable cost nest eggs by utilizing the economic systems of scale equation. It is more hard to account for the intangible effects as the equation does non take into history the hidden costs associated with outsourcing.

The fixed costs associated with outsourcing likely history for the web necessary to reassign merchandise and cognition between the outsourced locations and outsourcing house. These costs are likely really touchable and can be balanced utilizing the economic systems of scale equation. It is more hard to account for the costs associated with the devastation of competitory advantage, the accomplishments of the American work force and the intangible effects on the economic system.

Outsourcing our Cognition

The United States tends to hold a comparative advantage in industries with extremely skilled labour and capital demands.

These extremely skilled workers possess a strong cognition base which contributes to the U.S. holding a taking border in the economic system. Several corporations have taken advantage of take downing their costs by outsourcing these occupations to providers overseas, enabling them to concentrate entirely on their nucleus competences. This shamble may look to cut down costs and better efficiency, but it besides distributes cognition and facilitates international spillovers.

The economic systems that receive the spillover benefit from the inflow of cognition and are able to utilize it to progress their ain economic system. “ If you rely excessively much on people in other companies and countriesaˆ¦you are outsourcing your encephalons where you are doing all the invention. ” As a consequence, the fight of the U.S.

engineering industry is placed at hazard as the competitory advantage associated with this work has been lost from U.S. control.

Further, the U.S. is forced to vie straight with developing states in an country that was antecedently monopolized.Aerospace makers, such as Boeing, have followed this theoretical account by cut downing their costs through outsourcing subassemblies ( such as engines and constructions ) . Their attending is so directed to core competences of design, piecing and selling aircraft.

While this construction has reduced Boeing ‘s operating costs, it has created the new job of cognition direction as concerns have arisen about whether or non technological expertness will be lost. “ In the aerospace concern, that means the spouses in other states now constructing the constituents may one twenty-four hours be constructing the whole jet themselves, thanks to the engineering, preparation and contracts Boeing has provided. ” To battle this inevitableness, the supply concatenation must now pull off the cognition that is exported to providers. While Boeing actively mitigates for this spillover, it is impossible to anticipate that all rational belongings associated with their work is protected.

Skills associated with aerospace building, such as High Precision Machining, have been developed in countries where the work is produced. These accomplishments may be regarded as intangible by the outsourcer, but they provide an country of expertness that a underdeveloped state can leverage to make new merchandises domestically. These new merchandises may non instantly vie with corporations such as Boeing, but they probably will in the long term. As such, the competitory advantage associated with outsourced merchandises is put in hazard and the cognition one time controlled by domestic production is lost. This phenomenon is a direct effect of outsourcing and could be eliminated through industrial bunch, as seen in Silicon Valley.Many economic experts would reason that companies could profit more if they formed industrial bunchs, similar to computing machine bit makers in Silicon Valley. Bunchs are groups of inter-related industries that drive wealth creative activity in a part, chiefly through exports of goods and services.

As a consequence of these bunchs, external economic systems of graduated table occur within the industry which increases efficiency. Forming these bunchs would extinguish cognition spillovers in foreign states, which would let the U.S. to keep their competitory advantage in the planetary economic system. If a company chooses to outsource they are put on the lining the opportunity of compromising company patterns due to reassigning this cognition. “ Each clip we transfer knowledge bases overseas, whether it be fabricating or engineering or research, that is a service that will evidently be performed by a viing economic system. And it is work that will non be done by the U.

S. economic system and our workers. The consequence is – it could turn to an progressively larger portion of the trade-deficit job — the consequence is farther force per unit area on the U.S.

economic system. ” Highly skilled occupations should stay in the United States to avoid costs associated with the loss of technological expertness.To extinguish the impulse to outsource extremely skilled occupations overseas, companies can integrate labour market pools. Harmonizing to Krugman, when external economic systems of scale exist within an industry they can make a pooled market of workers with extremely specialised accomplishments. This market is advantageous for the industry and the workers because it maintains a changeless supply of knowing workers and lowers the hazard of unemployment within that part.

This pool enables companies to leverage their expertness and resources and omit the possibility of international spillovers. By being in close propinquity with each other, these companies can easy merchandise cognition and new thoughts amongst themselves, therefore increasing productiveness. Although a foreign state may be able to bring forth goods more cheaply ( as seen below ) , these U.S. bunchs maintain a competitory advantage within the economic system through inter-industry trade. Localized cognition spillovers are cheaper because they eliminate transit costs and consequence in increasing returns to scale within the industry.

In add-on to international cognition spillovers, another long-run affect that poses a menace to the American economic system is the deficiency of local endowment available to use. The outsourcing tendency has affected college registration because of the uncertainness that now exists with outsourcing skilled occupations.

Interrupting Education in America

The fright of outsourcing is striking a chord with America ‘s future employees. Recently, the instruction system has seen displacements in college registration, as college pupils have begun to eschew hi-tech Fieldss like computing machine scientific discipline and even technology. With the deficiency of stableness in these Fieldss pupils are concerned that their occupations could finally be outsourced internationally and are hence make up one’s minding to concentrate on their concern accomplishments. The war for endowment is at its fiercest in high-tech industries which poses a menace to the hereafter of the American engineering industry and the overall economic system. American companies may be forced to see outsourcing non merely to salvage costs, but due to miss of local endowment. Surveies have shown that the proportion of incoming undergraduates be aftering to major in computing machine scientific discipline is now 70 % below its extremum in the early 1980s.

Companies are go oning to transport IT operations to developing states such as India and China, capitalising on top-quality workers with local cognition. These other states are puting to a great extent in instruction and preparation in order to pull and retain the best endowment and to assist keep a competitory border in the economic system. “ Every twelvemonth India produces about 2.5 million university alumnuss, including 400,000 applied scientists and 200,000 IT professionals. It is estimated that India has 28 % of the universe ‘s IT offshore endowment. The cost of an Indian alumnus is approximately 12 % of that of an American 1. ” These are merely a few of the advantages that India brings to the market, which is why the outsourcing roar continues to turn.

Why are pupils traveling to major in these Fieldss with the premise that their occupations could be sent overseas to salvage a vaulting horse?The figure below shows the package and computing machine services sector, where many immature college alumnuss found employment over the last decennary. This sector is peculiarly relevant to the offshoring argument and its net occupation losingss were peculiarly steep in the last recession. Even today, employment remains good beneath its pre-recession extremum, even as package investing has to the full recovered.Outsourcing appears to work contrary to the claim that free trade will make better occupations in the U.S. These better occupations, which are normally hi-tech, white neckband occupations, are now being transferred to foreign states which limit chances for extremely educated Americans. The U.

S focuses so much attending on higher instruction yet people can non set their accomplishments or endowment to utilize if their occupation is outsourced. “ When fabricating occupations started traveling overseas in larger Numberss, American workers were told by free trade ideologists non to worry, that the U.S. comparative advantage was in services-especially high-tech and other knowledge-based industries. Displaced workers were told to merely get better accomplishments and more instruction in order to win in the changing American economic system. Many workers did, but now they find that cognition and endowment ca n’t vie against the pursuit for higher net incomes and cheaper labour in the new planetary market place. ” If Americans decide non to put in their instruction, companies will extenuate their opportunities of prolonging a strong knowledge-base within the U.

S. and bring on the hazard of international spillovers.

The Escalating Trade Deficit

The increasing trade shortage has a long-run consequence on the economic growing of the U.S. It slightly reflects on the comparative strength of America ‘s economic system and shows that we continue to devour more than we produce.

The U.S. can non shut its trade shortage if its economic system continues to be moved offshore. Outsourcing may hold a minimum affect on the trade shortage, nevertheless it still contributes to the U.S. exporting fewer goods and services. When occupations are outsourced, the consequence is the devastation of an American occupation. Goods and services produced in the U.

S. ( exports ) are now being outsourced overseas and imported back to the U.S. , therefore increasing the trade shortage. The figure below depicts the one-year trade shortage that started to roll up in the early 1980s.

Outsourcing reduces the buying power of workers and reduces their presence in the consumer market. When unemployment occurs as a consequence of outsourcing, these consumers do little to assist excite the economic system. Keeping occupations in the U.S. may minimally impact the shortage, but it can assist lend to beef uping the overall economic system.


Outsourcing has transformed the ways in which states interact. Corporations have fragmented their operations internationally in order to concentrate entirely on their nucleus competences. Short-run benefits, such as cost nest eggs were identified, nevertheless several intangible effects and concealed costs were overlooked that will hold an consequence on the U.

S. economic system in the subsequent old ages in front. There is still a batch we do non cognize about outsourcing, mostly because the available information does non supply information needed to to the full understand its magnitude, the grounds behind it, and the existent effects it has on the economic system. However, there is still significant information that can be examined to analyse the long-run effects that will change our economic position.

The sudden addition in outsourcing extremely skilled professional occupations may be suspending our place in the universe as a lead economic power. Companies must recognize that their strategic advantages will boom based on maximising their knowledge-base, which is achieved through using extremely educated U.S. workers.


  1. McCarthy, John P. Forrester Research. 2002.
  2. Wikipedia.


  3. Kallender, Paul. “ Gates Warns Against Reliance on Outsourcing. ” InfoWorld. 29 July 2005..

  4. Jorge, Niosi & A ; Majlinda, Zhequ. “ Aerospace Bunchs: Local or Global Knowledge Spillovers? ” March 2005..
  5. Virgin, Bill. “ Global Economy Complicates Outsourcing.

    ” Seattlepi.com. 24 January 2006..

  6. Bureau of Economic Analysis and Bureau of Labor Statistics..

  7. Fleischer, Jeff. “ Exporting America: An Interview with Lou Dobbs. ” MotherJones.

    7 February 2005..

  8. Economic Research Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis..
  9. Krugman, Paul R.

    & A ; Obstfeld, Maurice. “ International Economics Theory & A ; Policy ( 7th Edition ) . ” ( p. 137 ) . Pearson Addison Wesley.

  10. “ The Battle for Brainpower. ” The Economist. 07 October 2006.

  11. Bivens, Josh L. “ EPI Issue Guide: Offshoring. ” Economic Policy Institute. 31 May 2006..