The Accounting Profession And The Public Interest Accounting Essay

In October 2004, the IASB and the US FASB began a undertaking to make a common conceptual model, conveying together the bing IASB Framework and the FASB Conceptual Framework. One aim of this model is to supply information about an entity to external users who may be unable to get the information through other agencies. As before accent is being placed on relevancy, comparison, understand ability, materiality and transparence. Presentation of comprehensive income statements is of import under these features. Under the Conceptual Framework of Accounting, one intent of the readying and presentation of fiscal statements is to “ help preparers, hearers and users ” ( IASB, FASB. , 2009, pg. 02 ) with primary users being investors ( potential/current ) . This implies that fiscal statements should be presented in the least complicated signifier which allows them to be prepared and more significantly interpreted with comparative easiness while still following the ordinances of International Accounting Standards.

This capable affair is both topical and timely. Banking entities, before this economic downswing, abused the place given to them by authorities, corporate administration and modulating organic structures via the development of cringle holes within the fiscal system and by carry oning in the ill-treatment of accounting criterions to emphasis their balance sheets deserving ( Kirkpatrick. , 2009 ) . It is of import that a full justified and unfastened set of fiscal statements is made clear to that of the user, now more than of all time, to correlativity in line with The Corporate Report ( 1975 ) and the ability of corporations “ to carry through its coverage duty ” ( Connolly, . 2009, pg. 04 ) .

We Will Write a Custom Essay about The Accounting Profession And The Public Interest Accounting Essay
For You For Only $13.90/page!

order now

Literature Reappraisal:

In this subdivision we will look at old research done on how presentation and formats enhance accounting lucidity and thereby assistance users and the populace in understanding and supervising an entities place.First, Pine tree states and McDaniel ( 2000 ) pointed out that presentation format of the comprehensive income statement affects investors judgements about the coverage entity and can impede them in treating the information given.

Tarca et Al ‘s ( 2008 ) examine the worth of two differing formats of income statement. This was achieved through the conductivity of an experimental survey into look intoing “ the possible benefits of supplying information via an alternate format of the income statement ” ( Tarca et al. , 2008, pg. 02 ) known as the matrix format ( Appendix ) . The associated relationship of the change to that of the matrix format was investigated through a comparable survey into the “ truth, trouble ( easiness of usage ) and [ the ] assurance of topics in pull outing specific informationa╦ć┬Žpresented in the matrix format comparative to the same information as reported under the 2005 version of IAS 1 Presentation of Financial Statements ” ( Tarca et al. , 2008, pg. 04 ) , leting for both clear concise comparings and sound testing of their hypotheses.

Their findings indicated that truth, velocity and assurance of topics in pull outing specific information increased under the Matrix Format. The truth, easiness of usage and assurance of informations extraction experienced by participants was of a important betterment. The findings of the research seem promoting and positively correlated to that of the matrix format, even though reviews of the survey happen it unsupportive ( Yolrabil 2009 ) and un-relevant ( Henry, Holzmann. , 2008 ) with clear defects ( King et al.

, 1999 ) .Hirst and Hopkins ( 1998 ) “ investigated whether clear revelation of comprehensive income facilitates sensing of net incomes direction by buy-side fiscal analysts and predictably affects their security monetary value judgements ” ( Hirst and Hopkins ( 1998 ) , pg. 2 ) . Investors must frequently seek through legion notes and non-financial information to place relevant information that better reflects the place of the entity. In an experiment, in which 96 analysts participated, Hirst and Hopkins found that a clear statement of comprehensive income additions transparence of net incomes direction and thereby gives a fairer and more accurate penetration into the entity. It is due to this enhanced transparence that in June 1997 the FASB issued SFAS No. 130, Reporting Comprehensive Income, which requires a full set of fiscal statements that reports an entities comprehensive income along with its constituents.

The aim of SFAS No. 130 was that “ if used with related revelation and other information in the fiscal statements, the information provided by the coverage comprehensive income would help investors creditors and others fiscal statement users in measuring an enterprises economic activities and its timing and magnitude of future hard currency flows ” ( FASB 1997, Para 12 ) .Initiates and Philips ( 2004 ) , nevertheless, found that where an entity suffers a loss from other comprehensive income they are more likely to expose this loss in the statement of alterations in stockholders` equity instead so in the statement of comprehensive income. This makes comprehensive income information less noticeable thereby conflicting with FASB 1997.Hunton et Al ( 2006 ) showed that describing comprehensive income in a public presentation statement decreases the possibility of directors prosecuting in net incomes direction. This is due to the fact the statement of alterations equity is non viewed as significantly in finding rating and therefore investors and the populace are less likely to measure it in finding entity public presentation.

Hirst et Al. ( 2004 ) examined how Bankss step and show their comprehensive income statement affects hazard and rating appraisal. They found that with a clearer and Fuller accounting presentation hazard appraisal can be more accurately distinguished and “ just value information is higher with full just value accounting ” .Barker ( 2010, pg. 2 ) “ addresses an of import issue of presentation in the fiscal statements, viz. the differentiation between, on the one manus, the duties and associated flows originating from the proviso of finance to an entity ( ‘financing ‘ ) and, on the other manus, all other activities of the entity ( ‘operating ‘ ) ” .

He found that no accounting criterions has a clear definition for funding activities and hence no consistent accounting intervention leting for incompatibility which may take to investors being unable to accurately separate between funding activities and other runing activities of an entity.Therefore, the grounds implies that presentation of comprehensive income can impact user ‘s determination, create an inaccurate contemplation of an entity and confuse users in geting at a judgement of the entities place. It is due to these old findings why I believe this is an interesting country to look into how the accounting profession and the presentation of the comprehensive income statement can act upon investors and the populace in ways which may non be in their best involvement.


My research will be an extension of that undertaken by Tarca et Al ( 2008 ) . They tested their hypothesis utilizing a sample of analysis, comptrollers and MBA pupils. They referred to analysis and comptrollers as sophisticated users and MBA as less-sophisticated users. However, as an MBA pupil, you are required to obtain at “ least three old ages of relevant work experience in a supervisory or managerial capacity ” ( University of Ulster.

, 2010 ) . You besides undertake at least two faculties refering that of accounting ( Queens University Belfast. , 2010 ) .

This means that, with the relevant work experience ( to which fiscal cognition would play a big portion ) alongside the academic acquisition offered, MBA pupils would hold a old cognition of fiscal statements ( and their analysis ) prior to the survey. Therefore, within the research sample frame, there is no representation of those that do non hold fiscal cognition but may be a primary user ( an investor ) . This group will be the chief focal point of my survey.The object of the undertaking is to construct a information set based on the above sample which can be used in proving three hypotheses:The research method I will adopted is similar to that adopted by Tarca et Al ( 2008 ) which was an experimental study, incorporated into that of a instance survey.An exploratory survey into the country of the income statement allows the research workers to “ seek new penetration ; to inquire inquiries [ and to ] clear up their apprehension of the job ” ( Arksey & A ; Knight. , 1999, pg. 133 ) associated with the current IAS 1 Income statement format.A assorted methods attack to the aggregation of informations will be adopted, tilting somewhat towards that of a more qualitative research paper with facets of quantitative findings “ which you would presume to be present within any fiscal based survey ” ( Ryan et al.

, 2002, pg. 133 ) .I will fix three fiscal studies, one in the current IAS 1 format ( Appendix 1 ) , the 2nd will be of Matrix format ( Appendix 2 ) and eventually the common conceptual model, convey together the bing IASB Framework and the FASB Conceptual Framework, this will let for the research to be both valid and generalisable as all versions of the fiscal statements will incorporate the same fiscal information, but in a different formats.The instance survey will incorporate opened complete inquiries ( non multiple pick ) which will include competence inquiries and re-measurement inquiries bespeaking a good overall graduated table of oppugning. The remotion of multiple pick oppugning gives the research workers “ the ability to synthesise and measure information or use cognition to complex jobs ” ( Williams.

, 1973, pg. 665 ) . Questions will be of the same nature of those asked by Tarca et al. , 2008 ( Appendix 3 ) .A cross sectional survey will be performed to “ see topics clip restraints ” ( Tarca et al. , 2008, pg.

191 ) and, sing the nature of the research subject, a longitudinal survey may non be appropriate and could perchance take to cogency issues in the long tally. This is peculiarly relevant sing “ the of all time altering accounting environment and International Accounting Standards ” ( Sawani. , n.d. pg 01 ) .

Anonymity will be given to all topics, formalizing the research in conformity with the codification of pattern on research moralss, Section 3.15, ( 2007, pg. 04 ) .Interviews could so be carried out from which topic would supply feed back on which format they found clearest. However, as the sample group will be working category I believe a simple questionnaire would be more appropriate ( less clip devouring ) and effectual. Subjects would be asked to notice on the undermentioned inquiries:Which format did you happen easiest to pull out information from?Would you put in the entity based on the information you extracted?Which formats helped/hindered you in making your determination to oppugn 2?How do you believe your preferable format could be adjusted to give an even clear place of the entity?With the feedback from the questionnaire along with the experimental study I would be able to prove my hypotheses and find the affects of formats and presentation on the extraction of information.Questionnaires will so be handed out to CAP1, CAP2 and FES pupils go toing Queens.

The questionnaires will be of a similar nature to that stated earlier with the chief inquiry being:With your accounting background how do you believe the current comprehensive income statement could be made more user friendly to the general populace?The feedback will supply a good footing ‘s for recommended alterations which may be correlated to recommendation give by the non-sophisticated users.

Expected Findingss:

Overall I would anticipate the simplest and clearest layout to accomplish the highest Average Accuracy, Competency and Confidence tonss with the lowest average clip taken. Peoples we old accounting experience would be expected to accomplish high tonss across all formats.

While those with minimium to no accounting experience would anticipate to hit rather ill on more complex formats.With a clearer layout topics should be able to find the possition of the entity along with any streaghts and weckness such as grosss in relation to disbursals. I would expected those with a history in accounting to hold more thoughts of how the comprehensive income statement could be made more efficient and effectual while non-sophisicated users manner have positions to do other proficient information clearer and apprehensible to the general populace.

Accounting information as we know has prognostic values. I would anticipate sophisticated users to take the best concerns to put in utilizing the bulk of formats. Non-sophisticated users may be unable to find future prognostic values if the format is ill-defined with irrelevant information.Besides it would be interesting to see if the general populace know what the histories are stating about the entity, what period the histories are for, how notes may break reflect the hereafter additions and losingss and how factors such as depreciation and reappraisals affect the histories.


Accounting is the “ systematic recording, coverage and Analysis of fiscal minutess of a concern ” ( investorwords ) .

It aids both directors and the public such as investors in doing determinations. It is a profession that demands lucidity and honest readying and presentation that reflects a true and just place of an entity at a give clip.In times of hapless economic scenes investors are more careful in make up one’s minding which concern to put in. Examples such as the dramatic lessening and bale out Anglo Irish Bank Plc by the Irish authorities indicate the demand for a clear and relevant presentation of one-year histories.Histories must be presented in such a manner that allows users such as investors and the general populace to pull out information which is meaningful and most significantly accurate and it is due to this ground I believe this country fits under the header “ The accounting profession and the public involvement ” .